Tag Archives: God

Two Strangers, Two Responses to Autism

Stranger number one:  A man seated next to me on the flight from New York City to Denver.   He was distressed and upset because of the extensive delays we experienced and assumed he would miss his connection home to Vancouver where his two sons and wife awaited him.  As he spoke to me, he looked over at Emma, seated in the window seat and who appeared to be sleeping, thumb in her mouth, head resting on her horse pillow, a small scrap of her green blanket clasped in her fist.  Her hair fell over her face, covering part of it.  He nodded toward her, “She’s tired, huh?”

“Yes,” I said, looking over at her and smiling.  Emma opened one eye and made a little grunting noise, before closing her eye again.

He asked me if I was traveling alone.  I explained to him that in fact we were all spread out over many rows.  Because of all the delays the airlines changed our seats, giving most of us middle seats, making it impossible to convince anyone to switch with us so that we might sit together.  At a certain point, I took a lapse in the conversation as an opportunity to pull out my book, Representing Autism.

“Are you a teacher?” the man asked.

I told him I was not, that my daughter was autistic and it was a subject I was particularly interested in.

“Ah,” he said, knowingly.  ”My eldest son is too.”

He went on to relate how his son had been poisoned by high levels of lead because his wife had drunk tea throughout her pregnancy from a samovar.  This was confusing as, strictly speaking, his description would make his son’s issues lead poisoning and not autism, but before I had time to think of an appropriate response, he told me that because they had him chelated he was now high functioning and that God had blessed him with a child who could speak.   And while I think it’s wonderful many people find solace in “God” I really hate comments like this, where it has to then be concluded that God is not blessing others with things like poverty, starvation, murder.  I know, I know, don’t get me started.  

He then told me his wife contributed to his son’s autism because it was genetic and “the mother carries the genes that cause autism.  That’s why more than 80% of them are boys.”  This last remark was so staggering in it’s complete lack of logic I was thrown into a state of stunned silence.  Then he capped the conversation off with a nod to Emma and asked, “Is she functioning?”

Do NOT say another word,  I pleaded silently, while also thinking,   You have the chance to say something that might change this man’s point of view.  But I couldn’t.  I was too angry and tired, the delays had taken their toll.  I had hit a wall, silently cursed this man and just wanted to escape into my book.  I no longer felt magnanimous or in the mood to offer an opposing view.  I felt hateful, furious and resentful.  I was disturbed by the man’s, seemingly unintentional, but never-the-less confused ideas of cause and blame, not to mention the casual comment about chelation coupled with how his son’s heart stopped twice while doing so and that didn’t even cover the comment about God, which would have taken me down a whole other path.

“Does she speak?” he continued.

“She’s autistic.   Her hearing is actually excellent,” I snapped.  ”And I do not speak about her as though she cannot understand.  Her intellect is as sharp as her hearing.”

“Oh!” the man said, taken aback.

All thoughts of offering patient opposing views in a kind tone went out the window.  I pulled out my book, a pen and my notepad and began reading.  End of conversation.  It must be said, this was not one of my prouder moments, but I didn’t have it in me, I just didn’t and it depressed me that so many are so misinformed.

The second stranger was a woman with two small children who asked me, as Emma and I were waiting for the bathroom, if I would keep an eye on her two kids so that she might use the bathroom.  Emma peered with curiosity at her daughter who was four-years old and son, who was not quite two.  ”Boy,” Emma said, pointing at the little boy.

“Yes,”  I said, kneeling down.  ”What’s your name?”

We learned that the children, Alice and James were also headed for Aspen on the same connecting flight as us.  Their Dad couldn’t go with them, but their Granma was meeting them in Denver.  When Emma and I returned to our seats, Emma said repeatedly, “Go see  Alice and James.  All go together to Aspen.  Go to Granma’s house and play with Alice and James.”

When we found the gate for our connecting flight, there was Alice and James with their mother who proceeded to ask Emma questions.  ”What was her name, how old was she, did she have a brother, his name, age, where we were going, etc.  All the questions she directed to Emma and she waited for Emma to answer, even when it seemed she might not.    A couple of Emma’s answers were somewhat cryptic, as when asked what she liked doing when in Aspen and Emma answered, “Make cake.”  But all in all it was really nice to see someone behave in a sensitive manner while respecting Emma’s need to process, giving her the time to do so. It was in stark contrast to the first stranger.

This morning when I told Richard I was posting this piece, I said, “I’m too tired to find the humor.”

“My brain is operating on a case by case, need to know, basis,” Richard replied.

And that remark made me laugh.

English: Looking south from Top of the Rock, N...

(Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Tolerance, Despair and Hope – Autism

A follower of this blog emailed me this morning about a new app for the ipad called, Pop It.  It’s a “book” that when one shakes the ipad, the perspective of the story changes.  The creator, an artist named Raghava, gave a talk on Ted.com, which is terrific – about perspective and tolerance of others and the role of art and creativity.  Listening to Raghava made me think of a book I am currently reading by the extremely talented and insightful theologian, James H. Cone.  His book – The Cross and the Lynching Tree is a deeply touching and powerful investigation of suffering and hope.  James Cone writes at length about the nature of faith, how God “could make a way out of no way”, how “hope could remain alive in the world of Jim Crow segregation.”

I do not claim to know of the existence, nor can I claim to know of the non-existence of a god.  I cannot even define that word.  It is not a word that holds any meaning for me.  But I do know what it is to struggle with hope.  Hope for Emma, hope for all our children who will grow up to become adults, who many will fear, ignore or just wish would go away.  Our children with autism are often misunderstood, in their inability to fall into line with societal norms they are in turn rejected by society.  The continued negligence and worse, abuse, of people with disabilities is rampant.  Their abuse is done by people who have deemed them incompetent, imbeciles and without value.  This is the common thread that exists in the abuse of all groups of people throughout history.  It is our intolerance of those we believe to be “less than” that makes us believe we have the “right” to punish, shun, ignore, hurt, torture and kill.

James Cone writes:  ”The cross is a paradoxical religious symbol because it inverts the world’s value system with the news that hope comes by way of defeat, that suffering and death do not have the last word, that the last shall be first and the first last.”

When I was in my late teens I began using food as a way to quell anxiety and emotions I felt incapable of dealing with.  My overeating turned to full blown bulimia and the bulimia became a way of life – for 22 years.  I remember when I finally stopped, the idea of “surrender” seemed antithetical to all I had, up to that point, believed.  I thought that if I just had more will power I would be able to stop the destructive behavior.  I believed that the bulimia was something I could control.  I believed that my lack of control simply proved how despicable I was, which only served to fuel more of the same behavior.  It wasn’t until I took a leap of faith – really took in that I was, in fact, out of control, that I received a respite from the behavior.  Early in my “recovery” from bulimia someone said to me, “don’t you think that if you could have controlled the bulimia, you would have by now?  Isn’t it true that in fact you have tried to control it all these years and this is where that control has gotten you?”  With a great deal of support from others who had eating disorders and had come out the other side, was I finally able to find a way out from under it.  In surrendering to the fact that I was unable to control it, was I finally able to find freedom from it.

I’m all over the map with this post, but perhaps some of these thoughts will prove helpful to someone else or if not at least encourage thought and conversation.

For more on Emma and our journey through her childhood of autism, go to:   www.EmmasHopeBook.com

Anger

The invisible hand grenade being tossed into a room – anger – whether it explodes or is a slow simmer, it is something I feel when I think of my daughter, Emma’s diagnosis.  To admit this, by the way, is something I rarely do.  It is unseemly, impolite, not what we do and certainly not what we admit to feeling.

But I do feel it.

I wish it weren’t so.  I’d like to think I could think it away.  However the fact remains – I am angry.  I would take away her autism, all the things that make up that word, all the behaviors, the neurological blips, the tangled mess that make her both hyper and hypo sensitive to pain, to noise, her internal inflammations, ulcerations, her rigidity, the obsessive compulsive tendency, all those things when added up that equal autism, I would prefer it was all gone, in an instant.

I went hiking with a friend yesterday who was telling me jokes.  One, about a guy who is allowed three wishes, which a genie promises to fulfill, made me think about my one wish.  Just one, I don’t need three, thank you very much.  My one wish is for Emma to have a neuro-typical brain.  That’s it.  Just the one wish.  I’m like everyone else, I can always add a couple other wishes if pressed, but that has always been and remains my one wish, the wish that blows all the others out of the water.  Please.  Let her brain repair itself.

I know my anger, the slow simmering rage I feel covers a whole ocean of sadness.  But honestly I prefer not to feel any of it.  And I usually don’t.  I either am too busy or I make the conscious decision to turn it off.  Yesterday though, while hiking, it all came surging back.  Like the flood gates had been pried open and try as I might, they were unwilling to be shut, until they’d had their say.  It is in this state that I reject God.  The God so many turn to is one I turn my back on.  I reject, actively reject, angrily reject.  I know this.  And yet, Emma’s autism, perhaps like nothing else, has created such a feeling of need for something beyond myself.  It is beyond a desire, it is beyond a craving, it feels larger than all of that.  It is a need for something, something I can lean on.  I have no sense of it beyond these words.  Perhaps one day I will.

For more on Emma’s journey and ours through her childhood of autism, go to:  www.EmmasHopeBook.com

Autism

I have avoided writing about something I think about a great deal when it comes to Emma and her autism.  It is something some people bring up when they hear of Emma.  Thankfully most people do not.

It is – God.

There, I’ve said it.

When Emma was first diagnosed more than a few people said things like, “Everything happens for a reason.”  The first time I heard that comment I felt as though someone had punched me in the solar plexus.  The air was knocked out of me.  I stood there as they went on about whatever they believed, the reasons they felt this had happened, but I couldn’t hear them.  I watched their mouths open and shut, forming words, but they may as well have been speaking in another language.

The second time someone evoked God, as in, “We only get what we can handle,”  followed by, “God must think you very strong.”   I had the where-with-all to reply, “You might want to check the current suicide rates, as clearly the God you believe in, is giving those people far more than they can handle.”  And then I walked away.  Touche.

These comments, the ones that upset me the most always refer to God.  People with strong, solid faith seem to have a strength or determination that I do not possess.  It is more than a decision that’s been made, it seems they believe they have some sort of power, a knowledge the rest of us can only hope for.  They come across as knowing, as though they had a special private line to God, a kind of state of the art communication device that the rest of us do not own.  Perhaps what they do not understand is how superior they seem or perhaps they do, I don’t know.  I know most are trying to be kind.  That they are not, does not seem to occur to them.

When people have said to me, “I could never handle having an autistic child,” and then they go on to their next thought – “It makes me think we are given what we can handle.”  I understand what they are trying to say, they are expressing their relief that their children are neuro-typical.  ”There but for the grace of God go I.”  I know someone who I like very much who made just such a comment, I was surprised when she said it, but I knew she hadn’t meant it to be cruel.  I know many people don’t know what to say when confronted with something that frightens them.  Disease, terminal illness, death, what can any one of us say?  Most of us do want to express our sorrow, we want to be there for the person who is going through the difficult time.  We want to bond with them, show them we are there for them.  Often our attempts are nothing short of just lame.  We end up saying something stupid, we walk away thinking to ourselves – Boy that was dumb.  Why did I say that?  But when people bring God into the mix, as though they need to bolster their thoughts, then it becomes more complicated and hurtful.

I get it.

I do.  I know none of the people who have said these things have meant harm.  They mean quite the opposite.  Still I wish they would think through their comments before they utter them.

For more on my family’s journey through my daughter, Emma’s childhood of autism, go to: www.EmmasHopeBook.com